Blog Post #5: Lacan on the Mirror Stage as Formative
Jacques Lacan’s “The Mirror Stage As Formative” discusses this stage that we go through as babies in which he refers to this as the “mirror stage” and how this stage can carry on throughout adulthood. He first starts off by using what he calls “comparative psychology” and he does this by comparing the intellect of a child to the intellect of a chimp. For instance he says, “The child, at an age when he is for a time, however short, outdone, by the chimpanzee in instrumental intelligence, can nevertheless already recognize as such his own image in a mirror. This recognition is indicated in the illuminative mimicry of the Aha-Erlebnis, which Kohler sees as the expression of situational apperception, an essential stage of the act of intelligence.” (1164) He then points out this sense of nature vs. nurture thing where animals, such as the monkey, imitate the reflection of images around it which in this case is nature, kind of something like an animal instinct that carries on through their adulthood as full-grown monkeys. Whereas the child will learn through the what they are taught and through experience rather than natural instinct because once upon a time we were all babies and as children we learned through a reflection of what we see around us and what we were taught which does carry on with us through our adult lives. This is where I can see why this is referred or being compared to a mirror because through life we see a reflection of ourselves not always knowing what others may see us as. From birth we are taught to be a certain kind of way and we learn through what our parents taught us and through experience rather than this natural instinct like the monkey. And that’s why I can also see how Lacan is tying this notion together with using the example of a child looking at its reflection in the mirror because babies look at this reflection trying to figure out the image in front them and the emotions behind and kind of lack this sense of self as he explains in his analysis. They lose this sense of self because they do not know how to interpret this reflection of themselves and this carries into adulthood because we continue to see images of thing and even look in the mirror today and not know what is going on and try to figure out this world surrounding us. Unlike the chimp, we have this perception of ourselves and we know that others have this perception of us and its natural human instinct to wonder what that is and the chimp does not have a clue nor really wonder what another’s perspective is of themselves. Finally, this is what Lacan is trying to convey to us we have and still go through this mirror stage where we look at ourselves and reflect on what we are and the image we see in the mirror.

